Proactive Management

Find Out More

Find out more about:
  Close Corporations
  Subchapter S Corps
  LLCs

Incorporate Now

Form LLC Now

Your Price Quote

Business Terms

FAQs

Services & Prices

Service Area

Finance Calculator

Planning Ahead

Privacy & Security

Contact Us

Site Map

Top



Compare Business Types

Corporate Organization:
How are corporate roles and positions organized?

Strengths and Weaknesses:
How does one form of business compare to another?


Regular Corporation ( C Corporation)

Incorporate Online Now!

Management and Control: This is the most common corporate structure. It readily communicates prestige and credibility to customers, suppliers, and business associates. By giving the business it own identity, separate from its founder(s), a corporation has the flexibility and added prestige to grow its own image and prestige beyond that of its founders or managers.
Shareholders are the owners of the corporation. Unlike other entities where the actions of one owner obligate all the owners, a corporate shareholder cannot bind other owners of the firm by their actions solely as a shareholder. The shareholders of the corporation elect the corporate directors and ratify the bylaws which set forth the management procedures of the corporation. The shareholders of the corporation meet at least once a year, to elect a board of directors. The directors are responsible for managing the business and affairs of the corporation, setting corporate policy, choosing and supervising corporate officers, declaring dividends, and recommending fundamental changes. Usually, the directors must be elected by enough of the owners to represent a simple majority of the outstanding shares, although a higher vote requirement can be required. Thus, those who hold a majority of the shares have ultimate control over the corporation. Corporate officers are responsible for managing the day to day affairs of the corporation. The roles and duties of directors and officers are often scrutinized using highly developed standards of performance.
This is the most common corporate structure. The corporate management style is very flexible. Usually, the larger a corporation is, the more control rests in the hands of top management. At the other end of the spectrum, closely held firms are often actively managed by its shareholders.
A disadvantage of the corporate form of business is the observance of corporate formalities, such as creating a board of directors, having annual shareholder meetings, and adhering to state and federal reporting standards.

Limited Personal Liability: In today's business environment it is more important than ever to protect yourself and your personal assets by incorporating your business as a legal entity separate and apart from your personal affairs. Your home, cars, boat, savings, and investments could all be at risk and used to satisfy any lawsuits, debt or liability incurred by the business. By separating personal liability from that of your business, you can limit the impact that business credit worthiness and lawsuits have over all aspects of your personal life. The shareholders of a Corporation are personally liable for the debts and liabilities of the Corporation only to the extent of the value of their shares. As stated above, a corporate shareholder cannot bind other owners of the firm by their actions solely as a shareholder. This has the effect of protecting personal assets from claims brought against the company and vice versa. Forming a corporation or limited liability company can provide the protection needed to give you peace of mind and make your business even more successful and profitable. In addition, limited liability allows a corporation to issue debt as a source of funding. A corporation's debt will have its own credit rating which relates to the operation and administration of the business separate but is separate and apart from the personal liability issues of shareholders.

Distributions: Corporate earnings remain within the company until they are paid out. Profits are distributed to shareholders via dividends, redemption of shares, or the repurchase of shares by the corporation. Dividends are declared at the discretion of directors.

Taxation: The profits of a regular corporation (C Corporation) are subject to double taxation. In effect earnings are taxed twice; once at the corporate level and again when profits are distributed as dividends to their shareholders. If a corporation meets specific IRS requirements, a corporation can file for Subchapter S Corporation status. This allows owners of an S Corporation to elect to be taxed only at the personal level, thus avoiding tax at the corporate level. The IRS requirements for electing S Corporation status are listed below under S Corporation.

Transferability: Corporate organization provides the greatest flexibility for the transfer of ownership. Shares of the business can be easily transferred, without significant adverse effects to ongoing operations. The firm can have an unlimited number of stockholders, and can also raise capital by issuing corporate bonds. By creating an identity separate from its owners, the business achieves a level of viability and continuation which lasts beyond the involvement of its founders, managers, directors, and specific shareholders.
Since transferability is less of an issue for corporations than for other types of business, it is easier to attract capital financing. Investing in or financing a business which stands on its own can be more appealing to investors and creditors than financing a business which has diminished transferability of ownership and credit and tax profiles which are based on the owners, not the business.
Since shares can be easily transferred, they can be used as rewards in employee incentive plans. By letting workers become owners, employees are encouraged to focus their efforts toward helping the firm achieve its long-term financial goals, instead of just working to meet short-term employee performance goals. This energizes people important to the firm's success to focus on share value and thereby increase the benefit to all shareholders. And by using an asset which the company or shareholders already own, the company can increase rewards to workers without increasing cash expenditures or employee payroll.
Also, a corporation can choose to have an unlimited life span. This allows shareholders to retain independent control of their ownership interests beyond the duration available for any other type of business interests.

Limits on the transferability of shares may include restrictive rights on ownership interests, such as right of first refusal, options, and buy-sell agreements. Corporations can also issue more than one class of stock if they want to offer differing interests in voting rights, distribution rights, and liquidation preferences.

Formation: Corporations are created in accordance with state statutes & procedures. Incorporators file the articles of incorporation with the appropriate state agency. The requirements of the articles of incorporation are determined by state statutes. States require that all new business corporations must name at least two corporate officers, a President and a Secretary. However, one person can hold a director position and all officer positions.
Texas and South Dakota Corporations Only: A corporation in these states cannot commence business until it has received at least $1,000.00 for the issuance of shares.

Still have questions? View our Business Terms or Contact Us



Close Corporation

Incorporate Online Now!

Only the following states in Proactive Management's service area offer Close Corporation Status:
Arizona, Illinois, Kansas, Minnesota, Missouri, Ohio, Texas, and Wisconsin.

Management and Control: This is a corporation whose shares, or at least voting shares, are held by a single shareholder or closely knit group of shareholders. Generally, there are no public investors and its shareholders are active in the conduct of the business. A Close Corporation can be managed in the traditional manner by a board of directors or it can elect to be run by shareholders. In the latter case, the shareholders perform the duties of the board of directors. Shareholders are usually active in the management of the company due to the limited number of shareholders permitted.

Limited Personal Liability: The shareholders of a Close Corporation are personally liable for the debts and liabilities of the Close Corporation only to the extent of their capital contribution. However, those shareholders managing the affairs of the business in lieu of the board of directors are subject to liability as if they were members of the board.

Distributions: Same as Regular Corporations

Taxation: Taxation of the corporation depends on the type of close corporation formed, a C Corporation or a Subchapter S Corporation. The profits of a Regular Corporation (C Corporation) are subject to double taxation once at the corporate level and again when profits are distributed as dividends to their shareholders. If a corporation meets specific IRS requirements a corporation can file for Subchapter S Corporation status and generally avoid tax at the corporate level. Also, the owners of an S Corporation may personally deduct losses the same as a partnership. The IRS requirements for electing S Corporation status are listed below under S Corporation.

Transferability: Transferability is limited to a close knit group of no more than 30 to 50 shareholders. Since shareholders are so involved in the operation of the business, limits on the transferability of shares and prohibitions against public investors are some of the attractions of this form of corporation. By limiting transferability using restrictions such as the right of first refusal and buy-sell agreements in the articles of incorporation or bylaws, corporate ownership is restricted to those who are most closely tied to the ongoing operation and continued success of the business.

Formation: A close corporation will have in its articles of incorporation a provision stating that "this corporation is a Close Corporation." Bylaws are generally not required if provisions normally included in bylaws are included in the shareholder's agreement. A corporation may be formed initially as a close corporation, or it may amend its articles of incorporation to include a statement to that effect.
Texas Only: A Close Corporation in Texas cannot commence business until it has received at least $1,000.00 for the issuance of shares.

Still have questions? View our Business Terms or Contact Us



S Corporation

Incorporate Online Now!

Management and Control: This firm elects to have the income of the corporation taxed directly to the shareholders of the corporation, in proportion to their ownership interests, rather than to the corporation, much like the way partners are taxed. This distinction is for federal tax purposes only. S Corporation owners receive the prestige and durability of a corporation, along with limited personal liability and centralized management, while avoiding the double taxation of corporation profits incurred by Regular Corporations. This corporate form is suited for small firms whose owners choose to be taxed as partners or sole proprietors. Shareholders are usually active in the management of the company due to the restricted number of shareholders permitted.
Like C Corporations, S Corporations must maintain corporate formalities such as a
board of directors, shareholder meetings, annual meetings, and annual reporting.

Limitations: The major limitation on the use of S corporation status is that only "eligible" corporations may elect S corporation status. Some of the requirements for S Corporation eligibility are:

  • Must be a domestic corporation.
  • Cannot have more than 75 shareholders. A husband and wife (and their estates) are treated as one shareholder for this requirement.
  • The shareholders must be individuals, estates, exempt organizations described in section 401(a) or 501(c)(3), or certain trusts described in section 1361(c)(2)(A).
  • Cannot have nonresident alien shareholders.
  • Can issue only one class of stock (disregarding differences in voting rights).
  • Cannot be an ineligible corporation:
    • A bank or thrift institution that uses the reserve method of accounting for bad debts under section 585,
    • An insurance company subject to tax under the rules of Subchapter L of the Code,
    • A corporation that has elected to be treated as a possessions corporation under section 936, or
    • A domestic international sales corporation (DISC) or former DISC.
  • Must have a permitted tax year as required by section 1378 or makes a section 444 election to have a tax year other than a permitted tax year. Section 1378 defines a permitted tax year as a tax year ending December 31, or any other tax year for which the corporation establishes a business purpose to the satisfaction of the IRS.
  • All shareholders must consent in writing to this classification.

If at any time the corporation fails to meet the above requirements, the S Corporation status will automatically terminate.

Liability: Same as Regular Corporation

Distributions: Distributions are determined by pro rata stock ownership since there is only one class of stock. Otherwise, same as a Regular Corporation.

Taxation: S Corporation shareholders avoid double taxation by having the firm's income pass through to individual owners so that income tax is figured only one time on the individual shareholder's tax return.

Transferability: Limited compared to other corporations since there is just one class of owners. The articles of incorporation and bylaws should provide that shares cannot transfer to an ineligible shareholder, thus automatically terminating S Corporation status, unless agreed to by the other shareholders. Capital financing can also be accomplished by selling bonds.

Formation: For legal purposes, under state law, the S Corporation is no different than any other regular corporation. To elect to be an S Corporation, a corporation must file a Form 2553 election with the Internal Revenue Service. This election form requires the written consent of all existing shareholders of the corporation.

Still have questions? View our Business Terms or Contact Us



Limited Liability Company (LLC)

Form LLC Online Now!

Management and Control: LLCs have greater flexibility in management and organization than other firms. Terms of this flexibility are defined in the firm's operating agreement. This is an agreement made between the members of the LLC and determines how the firm's business will be conducted. This agreement is similar to the bylaws of a corporation with some characteristics of a partnership agreement. It is generally established at the organizational meeting, which should be held shortly after the Secretary of State approves the Articles of Organization. The Agreement sets the rules for management of the company as well as the rights and responsibilities of the members (owners). The members may manage the LLC themselves or choose to appoint managers and delegate management of the LLC to the managers. A member of the LLC can also act as a manager or a group of members can act as Managers.
A limited liability company is an unincorporated business entity that shares some of the aspects of S Corporations and Limited Partnerships, and yet has more flexibility than these more traditional business entities. The LLC is a fairly new type of business entity that is designed to be taxed like a partnership but offer its members limited liability like that enjoyed by the shareholders of a corporation. The LLC is designed to provide its owners with limited liability and pass-through tax advantages without the restrictions imposed on S Corporations and Limited Partnerships.

Limited Personal Liability: The members (owners) and managers of an LLC, like the shareholders of a corporation, are personally liable for the debts and liabilities of the LLC only to the extent of their capital contribution.

Distributions: As in a partnership, the members decide how to allocate the income and losses, and thus the tax liability among themselves. Amounts paid out which are not guaranteed are considered distributions.

Taxation: Default taxation for an LLC is pass through taxation. An LLC with just one member defaults to sole proprietor tax status and LLCs with two or more members defaults to partnership tax status. However, LLC can elect to change from their default tax status to corporate tax status, by petitioning the IRS for an entity classification election. To make this election, the business entity seeking a change in status must already have received or applied for its own employer identification number.
In order to avoid any revocation of pass-through tax flow status, the organization should involuntarily dissolve upon the execution of specific events. Members are taxed on their share of the income, regardless of distributions, partners may deduct active losses to the extent of the partnership basis.

Transferability: Subject to approval by other members; duration typically limited in time; operating agreement restrictions may limit the possibility. Also, transferability of ownership interests is generally limited unless otherwise addressed in the articles of incorporation. Multiple classes of ownership interests are permitted.

Formation: Must file articles of organization which are similar to the Articles of Incorporation a corporation must file. Organizers must file documentation with the appropriate state agency. The requirements of the Articles of Organization are set out in state statutes.

Still have questions? View our Business Terms or Contact Us


Disclaimer - Not Providing Legal Services - Proactive Management, Inc. presents the material on this site as general information only. It is not offered as and does not constitute legal advice or legal opinion and should not serve as a substitute for advice from an attorney or accountant familiar with the facts of your specific situation. We provide business formation services. We are not a law firm an